Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Shawn K's avatar

i think the points you are countering and your own points are both right, just operating in different timescales.

automation is increasing, jobs are being replaced, and its going to get extremely bad as the unimaginative top 1% will try to maintain a death grip on business as usual and not be willing to cede a dollar of profits for the sake of human wellbeing and social wellbeing.

the real question is just how bad will it get before real change happens? what is the actual tipping point where trying to uphold "business as usual" is actually more expensive to the bottom line and to society than it is to rewrite the rules of the game and move to UBI and a post-labor future?

If the behavior and choices of the 1% throughout history are any indication, i think things are going to get catastrophically bad before they eventually get better. we will eventually find out what new jobs look like in the new AI world, we may eventually pass UBI and have a whole fundamentally different understanding of our relationship to work. but i suspect it will be too little too late as we are stuck in the entrenched ways of wage slavery and we are in for the roughest next 20 years ever

Expand full comment
Tonecolor's avatar

You’re not taking into account the true nature of the change. This isn’t just some chatbot who is going to automate the dumbass jobs. The nature of consumption will change. It’ll lead to automated socialism, enough to survive and then those who want “more” will find creative ways to contribute using the AI.

Expand full comment
17 more comments...

No posts